Best Carnival Cruise Line Alternatives
The five cruise lines most like Carnival Cruise Line, what they share with it, and where they differ.
Carnival is cheap and cheerful, but some travelers want better food, a quieter crowd, or newer ships than the older vessels that run many of its short sailings.
Short answer: the closest alternative to Carnival Cruise Line is MSC Cruises, and for a step up, try Royal Caribbean.
5 cruise lines like Carnival Cruise Line
1. MSC Cruises
Value · 23 shipsBig modern ships at low fares, a strong Mediterranean program and frequent kids-sail-free offers.
Like Carnival Cruise Line- ✓ Similar value price level
- ✓ Also built for families
- ✓ Big resort-style ships too
- ✓ Also strongest in the Caribbean
Different from Carnival Cruise LineA very close match: similar price, feel and ships.
Best for: Budget-minded families and travelers who want Europe at a good price
2. Royal Caribbean
Mid-range · 30 shipsThe biggest ships at sea, with waterparks, surf simulators, Broadway-style shows and a private island in the Bahamas.
Like Carnival Cruise Line- ✓ Also built for families
- ✓ The same lively, high-energy feel
- ✓ Big resort-style ships too
- ✓ Also strongest in the Caribbean
Different from Carnival Cruise Line- ↔ Usually pricier (mid-range)
- ↔ Stronger food
Best for: Families and active travelers who want the most to do on board
3. Costa Cruises
Value · 8 shipsAn Italian-style cruise at good prices, mainly in the Mediterranean and Northern Europe.
Like Carnival Cruise Line- ✓ Similar value price level
- ✓ Big resort-style ships too
Different from Carnival Cruise Line- ↔ Stronger food
Best for: Value travelers who want a European feel
4. Margaritaville at Sea
Value · 3 shipsShort, laid-back cruises from Florida with a beach-bar feel, at low fares.
Like Carnival Cruise Line- ✓ Similar value price level
- ✓ The same lively, high-energy feel
- ✓ Also strongest in the Caribbean
Different from Carnival Cruise Line- ↔ Much less aimed at kids
- ↔ Smaller ships with fewer guests
Best for: Groups and first-timers who want a short, cheap getaway
5. Norwegian Cruise Line
Mid-range · 21 shipsNo fixed dinner times, go-karts and big shows on the newer ships, and Studio cabins designed for solo travelers.
Like Carnival Cruise Line- ✓ The same lively, high-energy feel
- ✓ Big resort-style ships too
- ✓ Also strongest in the Caribbean
Different from Carnival Cruise Line- ↔ Usually pricier (mid-range)
- ↔ Stronger food
Best for: Flexible travelers, teens and solo cruisers
Pick by what you want instead
The closest line to Carnival Cruise Line in each direction.
Carnival Cruise Line vs the alternatives
| Cruise line | Price level | Kids | Feel on board | Ship size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carnival Cruise Line | Value | Excellent | Lively | big |
| MSC Cruises | Value | Excellent | Mostly lively | big |
| Royal Caribbean | Mid-range | Excellent | Lively | big |
| Costa Cruises | Value | Good | Mostly lively | big |
| Margaritaville at Sea | Value | Some facilities | Lively | Mid-sized |
| Norwegian Cruise Line | Mid-range | Good | Lively | big |
These are our own judgments of each line's usual style, not any one ship or sailing. Not sure which suits you? Take the cruise line quiz.